WoW: Blizzard comments on external cooldowns like Soul of Power
The fact that your teammates improve your performance and vice versa is not only part of WoW, but actually of every MMORPG. Usually, these are buffs that you distribute to your allies to increase their performance in battle. But also external cooldowns have always existed in WoW. Some of them, such as Battlelust and Heroism, strengthen the entire raid, others, such as Windfury Totem, only strengthen your own party, and still others, such as Soul of Power, act as a cooldown for a single player.
The latter have been a thorn in the side of many players for some time. The players in question have to decide who to buff with it, so they usually don't cast Soul of Power on themselves, but on the strongest damage dealer. They sacrifice their own damage to increase that of others - which often doesn't feel very satisfying.
11:26WoW Patch 9.2: Developer video on the end of eternity
Blizzard comments on external cooldowns
Since this topic was one of the first to be discussed in the new Community Council forum, Blizzard's developers have now also commented on it.
They acknowledged that this is an extremely exciting but also difficult topic, which is seen differently depending on the preferences of the players. Basically, there would be two approaches: What's best for the group and what's best for me.
The developers want to make sure that the former always feels satisfying, but the latter doesn't get lost. Especially since it's hard to tell who contributed how much to defeating a boss.
Instead of casting on themselves, most priests cast Soul of Power on an ally.
Source: buffed
Abilities like the Soul of Power are used stacked to generate any record logs, which is perfectly okay with the developers. However, they rather focus on the social interaction that is needed with such abilities. They also see no reason to deviate from the concept at the moment. Only a few abilities fell into this category. And to abolish such a mechanic so that logs are more readable and pushed logs no longer exist would currently be going too far for them.
Official statement from Blizzard
Here you can find the complete statement of the Blizzard developers from the Community Council Forum:
Blizzard
This is a good topic, and a difficult one because it gets to a lot of questions about varying player tastes. No definitive answer-and we want people to keep talking about it-but a few thoughts:
One goal you have might be maximizing your chances at killing the boss. Another goal you have might be maximizing your position on a ranking website. Those goals sometimes lead you toward different behavior. It's not really up to us to tell people which one to pursue. But we do design towards keeping the first one interesting and rewarding. Choices where players are explicitly thinking about maximizing the group's output (things like external buffs, or group-level cooldown coordination) contribute to that. These can sometimes make the second goal less clear (for example, because buffs make it hard to account for everyone's damage contribution), and so far we are okay with that.
Another way of looking at this is: the "killing the boss" goal is made by us. The "ranking" goal is made and managed by players. Players can-and should-do what they want with it. Adaptations like asterisking logs which include Power Infusion are already occurring. The rankings are an expression of what players choose to value, to use as a mark of individual achievement. We all know that someone's value to a group is not solely determined by their DPS meter, even though it's a useful tool. Guild recruiters evaluating players know that various kinds of contributions aren't reflected there. Contributions like Power Infusion aren't obvious on them either, but similarly, that is an analysis problem left to players.
One of the most difficult aspects of this topic is social tension. Sometimes people argue with their teammates about buffs. It's very understandable, to me, why one possible response someone might have for that is-this can put you at odds with your own groupmates, so stamp it out. The flip side of that is: this is part and parcel of playing with real people in a large cooperative group. And preserving the human element of group play in WoW (buy now ), not boiling it down to predictable mechanical interactions, is an important value. See for example, the common lament that group-finder content has lost a lot of the human interaction from the experience. Mechanics that involve interacting with groupmates bring out both the good and the bad of that, and that might be better than having neither.
Trying to be as transparent as possible: so far we have not constrained our designs to require meter/ranking clarity and fairness, where doing so would compromise other values. On a gut level, a simple, compelling, familiar RPG concept is: one thing your class can do is give one person a buff. It's a minority of abilities in WoW, but it would feel like a huge step to say: that is no longer valid concepting for WoW abilities at all-that enabling high-fidelity ranking is so important that a certain ability design space is closed off.
Do you share the developers' opinion or do you think external cooldowns like Soul of Power should be removed from the game?
Support buffed - it only takes a minute. Thank you!Do you like buffed? Then you can support us as a buffed supporter so that we can continue to offer our content for free in the usual form without introducing a paywall.
Every amount, big or small, is valuable.
We thank you.
Also read these interesting stories 0
